FREE ESSAY ON DBQ FEDERALIST VS. ANTIFEDERALIST

DBQ FEDERALIST VS. ANTIFEDERALIST

Federalist DBQ
It can be argued that the Federalists were the first political party in the United
States. Their goal was simple; to unite the states and form a strong central government.
There were various attempts at uniting the states, the first of which was the Articles of
Confederation. These articles were not effective due to the fact that they did not have
the power to tax the States or the power to enforce a uniform commercial policy. This
caused the government to basically go bankrupt, and when this occurred, it was evident
that the Federalists had failed in their plan of union. Their next attempt, the
Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia, was successful in uniting the States, but
still lacked the necessary acceptance of the people. Due to the failure of the Articles,
the people did not trust the Federalists who created them, and in effect, would not allow
those same men to gain supreme power of the country by creating a strong central
government. The Federalists were not successful in handling the problems that faced this
newly created nation because they lacked the power of a strong central government.
The people of the United States were not satisfied with the way that the government was
handling matters which pertained directly to them; which was without their consent. This
is shown in the case of the Whiskey Rebellion (Document D). The Whiskey Tax was
implemented due to the fact that the federal government needed to raise money to pay off
state debts. Hamilton's plan was to tax Jefferson's supporters; this way he would not
lose any of his own supporters, and at the same time he would be raising the necessary
funds with which he would pay off the states debts. The fact that the farmers took
violent action against government officers, such as tax collectors and federal marshals,
shows that this government was not as strong as it thought it was, in that the people
still thought that violence was an acceptable measure in accomplishing your goals. The
Treaty of New York with the Creeks (Document A) is another example of the government
passing laws without the consent of the people. People did not feel that this treaty was
just, because ceasing their alliance with France, who helped them in the war, and
starting a "friendship" with the Native Americans who fought against them in the war, was
not a smart thing to do (Document C). This treaty, as well as the Whiskey Rebellion, are
examples of the Federalist government being selfish, and putting their own personal
beliefs over those of the people. The men who ran the government were not kings; they
were representatives; and the fact that they enacted laws which portrayed what they
wanted, and not what the people for whom they were representing wanted, shows that this
republic was not a strong government simply based on the fact that in a republic, power
is supposed to come from the people; and the ideas of the people should therefore be the
ideas which are acted upon by the government (Document E).
The fact that the government had to spend time fighting internally contributed greatly to
its general weaknesses. The reason that fighting took place was because the government
was run by two sets of people: the Republicans and the Federalists. These groups had
conflicting opinions on many, if not all, of the issues that were discussed while they
were in session. One of their arguments was based on the Alien and Sedition Acts, which
were created and passed by the largely Federalist government of the time. These acts gave
the government power that was clearly unconstitutional, but since the Federalists were in
charge and the acts benefited them, they were passed. The Republican's argument against
these acts was explained in the Virginia Resolutions and the Kentucky Resolutions
(Document I). These resolutions explained that the power being given to the federal
government by these acts was unconstitutional, and the power which was in fact
constitutional, was constitutionally that of the states. Arguments such as this took a
lot of time to complete, and in the end, they were counterproductive. The Federal
government was not able to comply with the rules that they themselves made in writing the
constitution; and if the government could not follow their own rules, they could not
expect the people whom they are governing to follow them either.
Although the Federalist government was not efficient in handling most problems facing the
nation, there were some areas in which they succeeded in fixing certain problems, which
in turn helped the nation as a whole. One major problem of this time was based on the
power of the State governments versus the power of the Federal government. One aspect of
this situation was the problem of who has power in court trials. The way that they
resolved this was with the Judiciary Act of 1789 (Document B) which made it so that all
crimes which infringed on federal laws, would be heard in district courts, which were
placed in each state, and all crimes which were not related to federal law, but rather to
state law, would be held in the states courts. This was one Federalist act in which the
nation did in fact benefit in the long run.
The people of the United States believed that the Federalist government was not
successful in handling the problems which it faced, and in turn the next government voted
in was Republican. The reason behind this is that with different methods behind their
actions, the Republicans were bound to accomplish more then the Federalists did. While
the Republicans were in power, there were many leaps and bounds that this nation went
though, and most of them were for the better. It is clear that this government is more
successful then it was under Federalist rule because for the thirty years after the
Federalists lost their political power, the nation prospered more then it did when they
did have the power.